Brickipedia

READ MORE

Brickipedia
Don't have an account?
Register
Register
Brickipedia
Brickipedia
40,005
pages
in: Nominations

Changes: Brickipedia:Articles for Rating/Class 3

< Brickipedia:Articles for Rating
Back to page
Sign in to edit
(Clearing older requests.)
Line 8: Line 8:
 
{{Template:AFR-nominate|Class 3}}
  
{{Template:AFR-nominate|Class 3}}
 
= Proposals =
  
= Proposals =
−
== [[TS22 T-Shirt, World City]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:LazerzSoH/signature}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' Hoping for Christmas points.
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
Eh...I don't know. It still looks like a c4 to me. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 02:07, December 21, 2012 (UTC)
  
−
{{Not Done|I'm looking at it and thinking it needs a lot of work before c3. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 13:57, December 25, 2012 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Damian Wayne]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' --[[Special:Contributions/50.99.243.145|50.99.243.145]] 06:38, December 26, 2012 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' I came across the page a short while ago and it looks like it has all the necessary information.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
I would like to see at least one more image on the page before promotion. The pixely one on there just isn't enough. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 13:36, December 26, 2012 (UTC)
  
−  
−
== [[Mafalda Hopkirk]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 06:29, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|{{User:Klagoer/sig}} 18:13, December 29, 2012 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Backlot]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' --[[User:ErkelonJay|ErkelonJay]] ([[User talk:ErkelonJay|talk]]) 19:23, January 4, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' If it doesn't go to Class 3, it should at least be moved to Class 4.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
<s>{{Not Done|C4 given. It could be a C3 if you add an infobox. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:03, January 4, 2013 (UTC)}}</s>
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:09, February 5, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[9783 Infrared Transmitter with USB Cable]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:SuperSpyX/Sig3}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|What exactly makes this c3? {{User:Cligra/Sig}} }}
  
−  
−
==[[6285 Black Seas Barracuda]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:'''{{LazerzSoH/signature}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|Too big of a set to have such a small description and lack of images. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 17:59, January 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[6005192 TC-14]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:'''{{User:Legoboy9373/sig}} 16:03, January 15, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|But you just cleaned up the article a bit, fixing some small errors and rewording things. Soupperson1 added the description. However, the description is copied from [[TC-14]]'s minifigure page (which I wrote). I can't and won't take credit for the article, but neither can Soupperson1 or you. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:40, January 18, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[4418 Dino Pod]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:SuperSpyX/Sig3}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|The lead section and description are mushed into one paragraph that in itself is pretty vague about the actual model[s]. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:33, January 18, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Cragger]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 01:32, January 19, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|"Jaggered" isn't a word, though. Jagged is. :P {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:23, January 19, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Greedo]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Legoboy9373/sig}} 16:49, January 19, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|Most of it looks pretty good. I'm appalled at the state of the description, though. If you clean that up, however, it could be c2. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:13, January 19, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Yazneg]]==
  
−
*'''Nomianted by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 02:30, January 24, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|I'm surprised you didn't just fix up the minor problems and get it to complete status after it failed its c2 nom. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 02:45, January 24, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Speedorz]]==
  
−
*'''Nomianted by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 02:30, January 24, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|-{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 18:22, January 25, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Peter Jackson]]==
  
−
*'''Nomianted by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 02:30, January 24, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|Already done apparently. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 18:22, January 25, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[LEGO The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' --[[User:ErkelonJay|ErkelonJay]] ([[User talk:ErkelonJay|talk]]) 00:32, January 26, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' With all the work done on this page, it needs C3 at least.
  
−
:Verdict
  
−  
−
==[[1235 Differential Gear Housing]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:SuperSpyX/Sig3}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
:Verdict
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:23, January 27, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[5242 Differential and Steering Elements]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:SuperSpyX/Sig3}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
:Verdict
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:24, January 27, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[2266 Extra Large Value Bucket]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:BrickfilmNut/sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' The infobox is complete and a detailed description has been added. Also included are the external links and a minifigure gallery.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|by someone else at least. Still has my ok on it. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 14:37, January 28, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[2581 School Bus]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:BrickfilmNut/sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' I completed the infobox and added a detailed description. I seriously can't think of what else to add: even when researching online, I couldn't find much information that couldn't be gathered from the image. :S
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|by someone else as well. Regardless, deserving. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 14:37, January 28, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Santa Claus]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' I think he looks alot better then most class four articles.
  
−
{{Done|It could do with a cleanup, but its current state is fine for c3. {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 18:50, February 1, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Ashlee Starstrider]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' Looks fine to me.
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:04, February 5, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[41005 Heartlake High]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' Looks good imo :P, I could be wrong tho
  
−
{{Done|Love it! I could see this making c2 easily too. -{{User:Nerfblasterpro/sig1}} 18:41, February 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Adi Gallia]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 21:39, February 11, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
{{Done|to c2. I can't see a reason why it shouldn't be... {{User:NightblazeSaber/sig}} 21:52, February 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−
* I would have nommed it for C2 but I thought that its amazing pictures might get in the way. {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 22:02, February 11, 2013 (UTC)
  
−  
−
== [[Pluto]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''I think it's fine.
  
−
{{Done|(Sorry it took so long to get to this.) It would be C2 if not for grammar and punctuation mistakes in the background. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 02:47, March 14, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[10517 My First Garden]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{u|Sanders7284}} on 25th Feb 2013
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' Description added, 3 additional pictures added, external links added, table updated.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|It still looks like a c4 to me. The description is a bit vague and doesn't describe a lot of the set. [[User:Jeyo|
  
−
<span style=" plainlink" title = "Jeyo"></span><span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
"><s>Jeyo</s> Lord Vladek</span>]][[User Talk:Jeyo|<span style=" plainlink" title = "Talk"></span><span style="
  
−
color:white;
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
">Talk </span>]][[Custom:Jeyo's Creations|
  
−
<span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-right:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
">The Forge</span>]] 21:24, March 4, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[30196 Shell F1 Team]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Legoboy9373/sig}} 18:14, February 27, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' This should have been rated c3 long ago.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|[[User:Jeyo|
  
−
<span style=" plainlink" title = "Jeyo"></span><span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
"><s>Jeyo</s> Lord Vladek</span>]][[User Talk:Jeyo|<span style=" plainlink" title = "Talk"></span><span style="
  
−
color:white;
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
">Talk </span>]][[Custom:Jeyo's Creations|
  
−
<span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-right:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
">The Forge</span>]] 21:24, March 4, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Warg]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Legoboy9373/sig}} 8:41, March 4, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:''' Added a background section and cleaned-up the description one.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|[[User:Jeyo|
  
−
<span style=" plainlink" title = "Jeyo"></span><span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
"><s>Jeyo</s> Lord Vladek</span>]][[User Talk:Jeyo|<span style=" plainlink" title = "Talk"></span><span style="
  
−
color:white;
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
">Talk </span>]][[Custom:Jeyo's Creations|
  
−
<span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-right:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
">The Forge</span>]] 21:24, March 4, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[LEGO Games]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:'''{{User:Track9876}} 12:08, March 5, 2013
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
{{Done|[[User:Jeyo|
  
−
<span style=" plainlink" title = "Jeyo"></span><span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
"><s>Jeyo</s> Lord Vladek</span>]][[User Talk:Jeyo|<span style=" plainlink" title = "Talk"></span><span style="
  
−
color:white;
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
">Talk </span>]][[Custom:Jeyo's Creations|
  
−
<span style="
  
−
background-color:black;
  
−
padding:2px;
  
−
color:white;
  
−
border-top:solid #910000;
  
−
border-right:solid #910000;
  
−
border-left:solid #910000;
  
−
border-bottom:solid #910000;
  
−
font-size:8pt;
  
−
">The Forge</span>]] 06:51, March 5, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Minnie Mouse]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:'''{{User:Soupperson1/Sig}} 21:30, March 15, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''looks like a class 3 to me.
  
−
{{Done|But for a few grammatical errors, it would be a c2. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 06:52, March 23, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Professor Sinistra]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 06:21, March 23, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 06:52, March 23, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Creator]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 06:50, March 30, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 17:41, March 30, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[132 Cottage]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''Its the same as [[341 Cathy Cat's & Morty Mouse's Cottage]].
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|The "background" ''almost'' gave it a red X. :P --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 08:42, December 3, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 17:22, April 5, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|Seems fine, if a little bare... {{User:Jeyo/sig}} 04:50, April 6, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[8194 Nitro Muscle]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 03:28, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|{{User:Klagoer/sig}} 13:44, April 7, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[4582 Red Bullet]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 03:39, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|{{User:Klagoer/sig}} 13:44, April 7, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[3706 Elmer Elephant]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 03:43, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
If another QCG could look at this because I frankly don't know. {{User:Klagoer/sig}} 13:45, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
{{Not Done|Same as the others; not enough information for a c3. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 17:34, April 7, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[852948 Female Magnet Set]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 03:52, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|{{User:Klagoer/sig}} 13:46, April 7, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[KCF27 Bunny Key Chain]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 03:56, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|{{User:Klagoer/sig}} 13:46, April 7, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[14 Small House Set]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 03:57, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Klagoer/sig}} 13:46, April 7, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[852354 Asajj Ventress Key Chain]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:38, April 7, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|Add a more descriptive price template and more detail. {{User:Klagoer/sig}} 01:55, April 8, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−
Oh, I don't know...it looks fine for a c3. Certainly not a c2, but that isn't what it's been nominated for. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 04:43, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−  
−
== [[Speed Racer (minifigure)]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 20:18, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:33, April 8, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Bill Ding]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 20:49, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:48, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[680 Low-Loader and Crane]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:06, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|No description. {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:45, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[65537 Classic Freight Train]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:23, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|No description {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:45, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Saarbrücken Opening Exclusive Set]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:28, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−  
−
== [[3788 Paulette Poodle in Her Living Room]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:37, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|No description. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[8850 Rally Support Truck]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 22:21, April 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|{{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:44, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[4224468 Santa Key Chain]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 00:21, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|No description. {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:44, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Part 30363px4]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 01:14, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|Outdated name (the official probably isn't available) and no description. {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:43, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[65468 Toa Metru Twin-Pack with Kanoka and Poster]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 20:34, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|No description or background. {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:42, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[5172 Round Bricks, Rocket Noses and Tails]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 20:38, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|No description {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:42, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[8638 Spy Jet Escape]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 20:38, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|No description {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:43, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[6289 Red Beard Runner]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 20:45, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not done|Per most of the ones above. {{User:Berrybrick/Sig}} 20:49, April 10, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[8884 Power Functions IR Receiver]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:14, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|Per above. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[970604 Friction Connector Pegs]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:17, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|No description. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[BIONICLE Ignition 13: Swamp of Shadows]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:17, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|Not enough information. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[1078 DUPLO Animal Mosaic]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:19, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|No description. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Voya Nui Online Game]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:47, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|Not enough information. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Specs]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Spiderlily|Spiderlily]] ([[User talk:Spiderlily|talk]]) 21:47, April 10, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|It's sort of on the border, but it doesn't feel like a c3 to me. {{C|If another QCG member disagrees, that's fine, I won't stop you from changing it.}} --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[850653 Michelangelo Key Chain]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 04:44, April 11, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 05:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Professor Sprout]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 20:22, April 19, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|By someone else. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 01:27, July 24, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Fenrir Greyback]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 20:22, April 19, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 01:27, July 24, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
== [[Dobby]] ==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 20:22, April 19, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|By someone else. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 01:27, July 24, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Two Minute: Quest of the Fellowship]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Sparrow9988|Sparrow9988]] ([[User talk:Sparrow9988|talk]]) 22:54, July 2, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Not Done|A little too scant, even for c3. --{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 01:27, July 24, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Pink Princess]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 01:27, July 24, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[850648_Leonardo_Key_Chain]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Darth henry/Sig}} 04:20, September 5, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 04:36, September 5, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Bard]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by:''' {{User:Legoboy9373/sig}} 11:34, September 5, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
*'''Nomination comments:'''
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done| -[[User:BobaFett2 | BF2]] [[User talk:BobaFett2 | Talk]] 16:25, September 5, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Lobster Guardian]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by: --{{User:ErkelonJay/sig1}} 20:50, September 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
**'''Nomination comments:'''Same level of quality as similar C3 articles, I believe.
 
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:55, September 8, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
−
==[[Barracuda Guardian]]==
  
−
*'''Nominated by: --{{User:ErkelonJay/sig1}} 20:50, September 8, 2013 (UTC)
  
−
**'''Nomination comments:'''See above.
  
−
;Verdict
  
−
{{Done|--{{User:Jeyo/sig}} 20:55, September 8, 2013 (UTC)}}
  
−  
 
==[[6487 Mountain Rescue]]==
  
==[[6487 Mountain Rescue]]==
 
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Pranciblad|Pranciblad]] ([[User talk:Pranciblad|talk]]) 21:50, November 16, 2013 (UTC)
  
*'''Nominated by:''' [[User:Pranciblad|Pranciblad]] ([[User talk:Pranciblad|talk]]) 21:50, November 16, 2013 (UTC)

Revision as of 11:26, 5 December 2013


Rating-3-glossy
Shortcut:
BP:CLASS3

This page is for proposing articles for promotion to Class 3 status. Only the members of the Quality Check Group are allowed to grant Class 3 status to articles without any consultation. However, every user is allowed to nominate an article on this page. It will then be reviewed by a QCG member who either approves or rejects the proposal.


How to nominate:
  1. First, nominate an article you find is worthy of Class 3 status, putting it at the bottom of the list below; see criteria above.
  2. A member of the Quality Check Group will then review the article for completeness and either approve ({{Done}}, 600px-Yes check.svg) or reject ({{Not Done}}, X mark) it, supplying reasons for doing so and ways to improve the article (errors, style, organization, images, notability, sources).
  3. The nomination will be removed three days after being reviewed, giving the nominator enough time to see the verdict. In case of rejection he may nominate the article once again after the reason for rejection has been addressed.
 To place a nomination, please use the following syntax:

== [[<article>]] ==
*'''Nominated by:''' ~~~~
*'''Nomination comments:'''
;Verdict

All entries should be moved to the archive after being reviewed.

Proposals

6487 Mountain Rescue

  • Nominated by: Pranciblad (talk) 21:50, November 16, 2013 (UTC)
  • Nomination comments: I'm positive that this article is better than most of the "infobox and maybe one paragraph of text" type articles that constitute most c4's. In fact, barring a gallery for the lone minifigure, it seems to fit the MoS like a glove.
Verdict
600px-Yes check.svg Done. --

Jeyo Lord VladekTalk The Forge 08:33, December 3, 2013 (UTC)


Barbarian (Minifigures)

  • Nominated by: -Legoboy 13:49, November 17, 2013 (UTC)
  • Nomination comments: Added a decent description and a good enough background.
Verdict
600px-Yes check.svg Done. --

Jeyo Lord VladekTalk The Forge 08:33, December 3, 2013 (UTC)


Lt. de Martinet

  • Nominated by: -

Power Jim Talk Blogz02:05, 12/3/2013 02:05, December 3, 2013 (UTC)

  • Nomination comments: Tidied it up a bit, should be fine for average article status.
Verdict
600px-Yes check.svg Done. --

Jeyo Lord VladekTalk The Forge 08:33, December 3, 2013 (UTC)

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.
More Fandoms